Subsequent performance

In warranty law, subsequent performance is the “paramedic” for a failed sales contract. If a product does not deliver what it promises (i.e., has a material defect), the seller first gets the chance to fix the error. This is not mere goodwill, but a statutory priority. Only if subsequent performance fails do tougher measures like withdrawal from the contract or price reduction come into play.

The two ways of correction

Here, the buyer usually has the agony of choice as to how the defect should be remedied:

  1. Repair: Here, things are screwed, soldered, or programmed—the defective part is repaired.

  2. Replacement delivery: The classic for mass-produced goods. The broken product is sent back, and a brand-new, defect-free item arrives.

Why all this? (Advantages & hurdles)

  • For the seller: They save the sale and may keep the product instead of repaying the full purchase price. In addition, the customer relationship (hopefully) remains intact.

  • The hurdle: Time is money. Long repair times annoy the customer, and logistical nightmares in return shipping can eat up the margin. In addition, the seller bears all costs—from postage to spare parts.

Best practices: How to make it run smoothly

Any company that does not want to sink into chaos should observe a few rules:

  • Talk to each other: Nothing is worse for a customer than radio silence while their device is in the workshop.

  • Speed matters: A quick response to defect notices prevents a small complaint from turning into a full-blown shitstorm.

  • Documentation is everything: Every step should be recorded—also to protect yourself legally if the customer later claims the repair failed.

To check whether the principle of subsequent performance has really been understood, these questions help:

  1. Priority check: Why is a buyer generally not allowed to withdraw from the purchase contract immediately as soon as they discover a small scratch? (Keyword: right to a second tender of performance).

  2. Cost factor: A seller charges the customer shipping costs for returning a defective vacuum cleaner for repair. Is that lawful? Briefly explain.

  3. “Disproportionality”: Can a seller refuse a replacement delivery (new device) if a repair would cost only €5, but replacement would cost €500? How does this affect the buyer’s right to choose? Explore further information for transparent repair documentation at repair fair.